Volume 12, Issue 3 (10-2024)
JRIA 2024, 12(3): 36-55 |
Back to browse issues page
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Abbaszadeh M, Karimi R. (2024). Identifying the values of architectural and urbanism heritage in urban development plans (case study: northwest region of iran). JRIA. 12(3), 36-55. doi:10.61186/jria.12.3.3
URL: http://jria.iust.ac.ir/article-1-1694-en.html
URL: http://jria.iust.ac.ir/article-1-1694-en.html
1- Faculty of Architecture, Urban Planning and Art, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran.
2- Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Urmia, Iran.
2- Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Urmia, Iran.
Abstract: (1520 Views)
Historic urban fabric are symbols of originality and identity in our city, and have high values. These structures, as architectural and urban heritage, have been inherited from our predecessors for us as a memory. Our responsibility towards this precious heritage is to understand its underlying values, and to preserve and promote it. But as it should be, the values of these textures do not have a proper place in the study process of urban development plans. Based on this, this research seeks to answer the question, what is the place of architectural heritage and urban planning in the description of services and urban development plans, and how can it take steps to achieve the right place? Based on the goal, the current research is practical and in terms of research method, it is descriptive-analytical. The strategy used is interpretive strategy and logical reasoning. The method of collecting information is library and documents. According to the type of research and its strategy, the present article can be called one of the qualitative articles. In order to achieve the goal of the research, first, the values of architectural heritage and urban planning were extracted based on the study of numerous sources, and then their place in the description of services of urban development plans was evaluated. Finally, by matching the extracted values with the service description of the (comprehensive) development plans of Urmia, Maragheh, Tabriz and Meshginshahr cities, it has been addressed to provide solutions for the practical realization of the place of architectural and urban planning values in the service description of urban development plans. With the arrival of modernism in Iran and the imposition of a new spatial arrangement resulting from it on the historical contexts of old cities, responding to the social and cultural needs of the residents has been forgotten. The multiplicity of procedures and their sectional nature and the impact of relevant policies from sectional decisions without philosophical and theoretical support is the bottleneck that developing countries are currently facing. Therefore; urban heritage cannot be imagined as an isolated phenomenon, an enclosed area that is protected from the external forces of change due to plans and regulations. The work process was such that first the values of architectural heritage and urban planning were introduced and a category that could be extracted from it was presented, and then a comparative study of the realization of these values was carried out in the description of study services of comprehensive and detailed plans, description of special and non-homogeneous services, and in the next step with the application of pathology, the reasons for its non-fulfillment have been studied in these plans. In this regard, in order to carefully examine the issue of the development plans of several cities in the northwestern region of the country, it has been studied. The results of the research show that urban development plans, as the most important urban planning documents in the field of paying attention to the values of architectural heritage and urban development and its application in order to protect this heritage, have performed poorly and the right place has not been considered for it. In this regard, the special plans for the protection and revival of the historical area have been successful in paying attention to the many values of the historical contexts and have covered many existing gaps, but they still have disadvantages. The comparative study of the types of architectural and urban heritage values shows that in the description of the services of comprehensive and detailed plans, the most focus is on historical and cultural values, while in the description of the services of special plans for the protection and revitalization of the area Historical-cultural, today’s values, which include a wide range of scientific-educational, tourism, economic, functional and political values, have received more attention. In summing up the reviewed experiences, it can be stated that although historical contexts did not have a place until several decades after the entry and implementation of urban development plans in the country, with the passage of time and the experience of the transition period, historical contexts have gained value and dignity in urban development plans; But this position is only summarized in physical and tourism values and identity, historical, social, economic, political and aesthetic aspects have been marginalized. In general, in urban development plans, one should avoid looking at historical textures as an island, so that other textures can be used as a support for old textures. In the following, based on the results, solutions are proposed with the aim of eliminating this shortcoming and the appropriate calculation and application of values in urban development plans, so that the study, review and presentation of a suitable plan in an integrated manner for the whole city in terms of the differences and unique characteristics of each part of the city can be a lot to resolve urban heritage issues.
Keywords: Architectural and Urbanism, Heritage, Urban Development Plans, Value, Historical Urban Fabric
Type of Study: Research |
Subject:
General
Received: 2023/07/19 | Accepted: 2024/08/17 | Published: 2024/12/28
Received: 2023/07/19 | Accepted: 2024/08/17 | Published: 2024/12/28
References
1. امانزادگان، الهام، و منوچهر طبیبیان. 1400. قرائتی بر بازآفرینی شهری پایدار در بافتهای تاریخی با تحلیل و ارزیابی تحققپذیری معیارهای آن در محلات بافت تاریخی شیراز. برنامهریزی توسعه کالبدی 6 (2): 11-28.
2. ایزدی، آرزو، شهریار ناسخیان، و محمود محمدی. 1397. تبیین چارچوب مفهومی بازآفرینی پایدار بافتهای تاریخی (بررسی اسناد، بیانیهها و منشورهای بازآفرینی). مطالعات باستانشناسی پارسه 2 (6): 161-177.
3. توانگر، معصومه و جواد فرهادی. 1401. اثرات اجرای طرحهای توسعه شهری در تخریب مکانهای باارزش شهر زیارتی- گردشگری مشهد. پژوهشنامه خراسان بزرگ 13 (46): 71-84.
4. حناچی، پیروز، و محمد پورسراجیان. 1391. احیای بافت شهری تاریخی (با رویکرد مشارکت). تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه تهران.
5. خوشاب، علی، خاکپور، براتعلی و ریحانه علائی. 1401. آسیبشناسی طرحهای توسعه شهری از فرآیند تهیه تا اجرا با تأکید بر طرح جامع و تفصیلی شهر مشهد. جغرافیا و توسعه فضای شهری 9 (3): 195-216.
6. رجبی، اسماعیل، کریم حسینزاده دلیر، و بختیار عزت پناه. 1400. شناسایی پیشرانهای کلیدی مؤثر بر بازآفرینی بافت تاریخی شهر تبریز با رویکرد آیندهپژوهی. فرهنگ معماری و شهرسازی اسلامی 6 (2): 211-237.
7. رضایی، محمد، سیدمصطفی رضاحسینی، و هادی حکیمی. 1391. برنامهریزی راهبردی مدیریت بحران در بافت تاریخی شهر یزد با استفاده از مدل SWOT. مدیریت بحران 1 (1): 35-44.
8. زارعیحاجیآبادی، فاطمه، نیلا پشمکیان، و صفورا شهابی. 1392. سنجش میزان رضایتمندی ساکنان بافتهای تاریخی، نمونه موردی بافت تاریخی محله حاجی همدان. آمایش محیط 6 (22): 101-119.
9. زنگیآبادی، علی، و سعیده مؤیدفر. 1391. رویکرد بازآفرینی شهری در بافتهای فرسوده: برزن شش بادگیری شهر یزد. معماری و شهرسازی آرمانشهر 5 (9): 297-314.
10. سازمان مدیریت و برنامهریزی شهری. 1383. فرهنگ واژگان نظام فنی و اجرایی کشور. معاونت امور فنی.
11. شجاعی، شیرین، بابک عالمی، و حمیدرضا جیحانی. 1400. حفاظت از ارزشهای شهری گذرهای تاریخی با تکیه بر آسیبشناسی گذر محله بالا در شهر نراق. اقتصاد و برنامهریزی شهری 2 (3): 134-146.
12. شورایعالی معماری و شهرسازی ایران. 1399. چارچوب شرح خدمات تهیه طرحهای ویژه حفاظت و احیای محدوده تاریخی- فرهنگی (مصوبه 05/08/1399).
13. _____________________. 1400. چارچوب، راهنما و شرح خدمات تهیه طرحهای جامع شهری با نگرش و رویکرد نوین (مصوبه 04/05/1400).
14. صادقی، سارا، محمود قلعهنویی، و صفورا مختارزاده. 1391. بررسی تأثیر طرحهای توسعه شهری معاصر بر ساختار فضایی هسته تاریخی شمال شهر اصفهان. مطالعات شهری 2 (5): 3-12.
15. صالحی، اسماعیل. 1399. کتاب سبز 1400 (راهنمای عمل شهرداریها)؛ طرح های شهری. جلد 5. مرکز مطالعات برنامهریزی شهری و روستایی: 1-163.
16. عباسزاده، مظفر، اصغر محمدمرادی، و الناز سلطاناحمدی. 1394. نقش ارزشهای میراث معماری و شهری در توسعه گردشگری فرهنگی نمونه موردی: بافت تاریخی ارومیه. مطالعات شهری 4 (14): 77-90.
17. عباسزاده، مظفر، اصغر محمدمرادی، آتسسا امیرکبیریان، معصومه آیشم، و الناز سلطاناحمدی. 1397. ارائه مدل ارزشمبنا به جهت کاربست ارزشهای میراث معماری در اتخاذ شیوههای حفاظت موردپژوهی: مجموعه میراث جهانی تخت سلیمان. مرمت و معماری ایران 8 (16): 142-125.
18. علویانصدر، مسعود، محمدسعید ایزدی، پویان شهابیان، و محمدحسین طالبیان. 1400. برنامهریزی حفاظت و توسعه یکپارچه فضاهای شهری برمبنای مؤلفههای منظر شهری. اثر 42 (1): 18-39.
19. فلامکی، محمدمنصور. 1381. ریشهها و گرایشهای نظری معماری. تهران: مؤسسه علمی و فرهنگی فضا.
20. قادری، اسماعیل، افسانه زمانی مقدم، و هاشم جلالی. 1391. تدوین راهبردهای اجتماعی مدیریتی احیاء، توسعه و حفاظت بافتهای تاریخی؛ مطالعه موردی منطقه 12 شهرداری تهران. مطالعات توسعه اجتماعی ایران 5 (1): 97-113.
21. کلانتری خلیلآباد، حسین، و احمد پوراحمد. 1384. فنون و تجارب برنامهریزی مرمت بافت تاریخی شهرها. تهران: سازمان انتشارات جهاد دانشگاهی.
22. کیانی، اکبر، فرضعلی سالاریسردری، و محمدصادق افراسیابیراد. 1388. بررسی هویتبخشی شهر فیروزآباد در بهسازی و نوسازی بافت تاریخی شهر گور با استفاده از تکنیکSWOT. آمایش محیط (6): 1-20.
23. محمدمرادی، اصغر. 1384. مرمت و احیای ساختمانهای قدیمی بهعنوان گامی در جهت حفاظت و مرمت شهر تاریخی. مجله بینالمللی علوم مهندسی 16 (1): 85-92.
24. مرکز پژوهشهای مجلس شورای اسلامی. 1399. مصوبه شورایعالی شهرسازی و معماری ایران پیرامون چارچوب شرح خدمات طرحهای ویژه حفاظت و احیای بافتهای تاریخی- فرهنگی (مصوب 21/10/99).
25. ملکی، قاسم. 1382. اقتصاد مهندسی ابزار طراحی نظام انگیزش نوسازی. هفتشهر 5 (15-16): 20-36.
26. مهندسین مشاور زیستا. 1399. طرح توسعه و عمران (جامع) مشگینشهر. اداره کل راه و شهرسازی استان اردبیل.
27. مهندسین مشاور طرح و آمایش. 1389. طرح تجدیدنظر طرح جامع شهر ارومیه. اداره کل راه و شهرسازی استان آذربایجانغربی.
28. مهندسین مشاور نقش محیط. 1390. طرح توسعه و عمران (جامع) شهر مراغه. اداره کل راه و شهرسازی استان آذربایجانشرقی.
29. ________________. 1395. طرح توسعه و عمران (جامع) شهر تبریز. اداره کل راه و شهرسازی استان آذربایجانشرقی.
30. هاشمی، الناز، و مسعود علیمردانی. 1399. بررسی ابعاد چارچوب مفهومی بازآفرینی حفاظتمحور در بافتهای شهری تاریخی ایران. شباک 6 (2): 33-46.
31. Abbaszadeh, Mozaffar, Asghar Mohammad Moradi, and Elnaz Sultan Ahmadi. 2015. The Role of Architectural and Urban Heritage Values in the Development of Cultural Tourism, a Case study: The Historical Context of Urmia. Urban Studies 4(14): 77- 90.
32. Abbaszadeh, Mozaffar, Asghar Mohammad Moradi, Atsa Amirkabirian, Masoumeh Aysham, and Elnaz Soltan Ahmadi. 2018. Presentation of the Base Value Model for the Application of Architectural Heritage Values in the Adoption of Research Methods of Protection: Takht Soleyman World Heritage Complex. Maremat and Memarie Iran 8 (16): 125-142.
33. Alavian Sadr, Massoud, Mohammad Saeed Izadi, Pooyan Shahabian, and Mohammad Hossein Talebian. 2021. Planning the Protection and Integrated Development of Urban Spaces based on the Components of the Urban Landscape. Asar 42 (1): 18- 39.
34. Amanzadegan, Elham, and Manouchehr Tabibian. 2021. Reading sustainable urban regeneration in historical Districts by analyzing and evaluating the feasibility of its criteria in the historical District of Shiraz. Physical Social Planning 6 (2): 11- 28.
35. Bandarin, Francesco. 2015. Introduction: Urban Conservation and the End of Planning. In Reconnecting the City. Edited by Ron van Oers. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell. [DOI:10.1002/9781118383940]
36. Chapin, F. Stuart. 1979. Urban Land Use Planning. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, Chicago, London.
37. Cina, Giuseppe, Elgar Kamjou, and Mahammad Reza Tavangar .2018. Learning from Urban Heritage Conservation in Yazd: Achievements and Warnings. The Historic Environment: Policy and Practice. 9 (1): 53- 77. [DOI:10.1080/17567505.2018.1424617]
38. Crawford, Thomas W. 2006. Urban Morphology and the Problem of the Modern Urban Fabric: Some Question for Research. International Seminar on Urban Form.
39. Flamaki, Mohammad Mansour. 2002. Origins and Theoretical Tendencies of Architecture. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Institute of Space.
40. Ghaderi, Esmaiel, Afsaneh Zamani Moghadam, and Hashem Jalali. 2012. Developing Social Management Strategies for the Restoration, Development and Protection of Historical Contexts; a Case Study of Region 12 of Tehran Municipality. Social Development Studies of Iran 5 (1): 97-113.
41. Hanachi, Pirouz, and Mohammad Poursarajian. 2012. Revitalization of the Historical Urban Fabric (Productivity of Participation). Tehran: Tehran University Press, first edition.
42. Hashemi, Elnaz, and Masoud Alimardani. 2020. Investigating the Dimensions of the Conceptual Framework of Conservation- Oriented Rregeneration in the Historical Urban Contexts of Iran. Shabak 6 (2): 33- 46.
43. Iran's Supreme Council of Architecture and Urban Planning. 2020. The Framework for the Description of Services for the Preparation of Special Plans for the Protection and Revival of the Historical-Cultural Area (Approved on 2020/10/26).
44. _____________________________________________________. 2021. The Framework, Guide and Description of Services for the Preparation of Comprehensive Urban Plans with a New Attitude and Approach (Approved on 2021/07/26).
45. Islamic Council Research Center. 2020. Resolution of the Supreme Council of Urban Planning and Architecture of Iran Regarding the Service Description Framework of Special Plans for the Protection and Restoration of Historical-Cultural Contexts (Approved on 2021/01/10).
46. Izadi, Arzoo, Shahriar Nasekhian, and Mahmoud Mohammadi. 2018. Explanation of the Conceptual Framework of Sustainable Reconstruction of Historical Contexts (Examination of Documents, Statements and Charters of Reconstruction). Parse Archaeological Studies 2 (6): 161- 177. [DOI:10.30699/PJAS.2.6.161]
47. Kalantari Khalilabad, Hossein, and Ahmad Pourahmad. 2005. Techniques and Experiences of Planning the Restoration of the Historical Fabric of Cities. Tehran: Academic Jahad Publishing Organization.
48. Khoshab, Ali, Khakpour, Baratali and Reyhaneh Alaee. 2022. Pathology of Urban Development Plans from Preparation to Implementation with an Emphasis on the Comprehensive and Detailed Plan of Mashhad City. Geography and Urban Space Development 9 (3): 195-216.
49. Kiyani, Akbar, Farzali Salari Sardari, and Mohammad Sadegh Afrasiabi Rad. 2009. Investigating the Identity of the City of Firozabad in the Improvement and Renovation of the Historical Fabric of the City of Gore Using the SWOT Technique. Environmental Studies (6): 1- 20.
50. Klebba, Jennifer, Mind.ed Garre, and Bryan.T Radle .2001. Downtown Redevelopment in Selected Oregon Coastal Communities: Some Lessons from Practice. Brayed. Michal.A. New York.
51. Levy, Albert. 1999. Urban Morphology and the Problem of the Modern Urban Fabric. Urban Morphology 3 (2): 79- 85. [DOI:10.51347/jum.v3i2.3885]
52. Maleki, Ghasem. 2003. Engineering Economics of the Design Tool for the Renovation Incentive System. Haftshahr 5 (15-16): 20- 36.
53. Mohammad Moradi, Asghar. 2005. Restoration and Restoration of Old Buildings as a Step towards the Protection and Restoration of the Historical City. International Journal of Engineering Sciences 16(1): 85- 92.
54. Naghshe Mohit Consulting Engineers. 2011. Development and Construction Plan (Comprehensive) of Maragheh City. General Administration of Roads and Urban Planning of East Azarbaijan.
55. ______________________________. 2016. Development and Construction Plan (Comprehensive) of Tabriz City. General Administration of Roads and Urban Planning of East Azarbaijan.
56. Rada, Deborah, R. 1999. Transformatonal Leadership and Urban Renewal. Journal of Leadership Studies and Organizational 6 (3-4): 18- 33. [DOI:10.1177/107179199900600302]
57. Rajabi, Ismail, Karim Hosseinzadeh Dalir, and Bakhtiar Ezzatpanah. 2021. Identifying Key Drivers Effective on Re-Creating the Historical Context of Tabriz City with a Future Research Approach. Culture of Islamic Architecture and Urbanism 6 (2): 211-237. [DOI:10.52547/ciauj.6.2.211]
58. Rezaei, Mohammad, Seyed Mostafi Reza Hosseini, and Hadi Hakimi. 2012. Strategic Planning of Crisis Management in the Historical Context of Yazd Using SWOT Model. Crisis Management 1(1): 35- 44.
59. Sadeghi, Sara, Mahmoud Ghale Noi, and Safora Mokhtarzadeh. 2012. Investigating the Impact of Contemporary Urban Development Plans on the Spatial Structure of the Historical Core of the Northern City of Isfahan. Urban Studies 2 (5): 3- 12.
60. Salehi, Esmaeil. 2021. (Guidelines for Municipalities); Urban Plans. 5. Center for Urban and Rural Planning Studies: 1-163.
61. Shirvani Dastgerdi, Ahmadreza, and Reza Kheyroddin. 2022. Policy Recommendations for Integrating Resilience into the Management of Cultural Landscapes. Sustainability 14 (14): 1-17. [DOI:10.3390/su14148500]
62. Shojaie, Shirin, Babak Alami, and Hamidreza Jeyhani. 2021. Protection of the Urban Values of Historical Crossings based on the Pathology of Crossing the Upper Neighborhood in Naraq City. Economy and Urban Planning 2 (3): 134-146.
63. Tarho Amayesh Consulting Engineers. 2010. Revision Plan of Urmia City Comprehensive Plan. General Administration of Roads and Urban Planning of West Azarbaijan.
64. Tavangar, Masoomeh and Javad Farhadi. 2022. Critical Analysis of the Effects of Urban Development Plans on the Destruction of Valuable Places in the Pilgrimage-Tourism City of Mashhad. Journal of Great Khorasan 13 (46): 71-84.
65. Urban Planning and Management Organization. 2014. Vocabulary of Technical and Executive System of the Country. Vice President of Technical Affairs.
66. Zangibadi, Ali, and Saideh Moayedfar. 2012. The Approach of Urban Regeneration in Worn-Out Tissues: Barzan Shesh Badgiri of Yazd City. Armanshahr 5 (9): 297- 314.
67. Zarei Hajiabadi, Fatemeh, Nila Pashmakian, and Safora Shahabi. 2013. Measuring the Level of Satisfaction of the Residents of Historical Contexts; a Case Example of the Historical Context of Haji Hamedan Neighborhood. Environmental Studies 6 (22): 101-119.
68. Zista Consulting Engineers. 2020. Development and Construction Plan (Comprehensive) of Meshghin City. General Administration of Roads and Urban Planning of Ardabil.
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
Journal of Researches in Islamic Architecture is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
